 |
| Sky, sea, land - nature's lesson in harmony |
 |
| Harmony in small things |
A visit to the Willow Cree Healing Lodge on the Beardy’s
and Okemasis First Nation got me thinking again about the three legs of sentencing:
retribution, rehabilitation, deterrence. Typically, these are given as the
three primary goals of punishment for crime.
·
Retribution: “You do the crime, you’ll do the
time.” “An eye for an eye . . . “
·
Rehabilitation: “We’ll make a better, law-abiding
person of you.”
·
Deterrence: “We’re making an example of you so
others won’t make the same mistakes.”
Of course, we use other terms as well.
·
Penitentiary is one whose root—penitent—Oxford defines as “feeling or
showing sorrow and regret for having done wrong.” Ostensibly, this could align
with rehabilitation, particularly under the Christian concept that penitence must precede rebirth.
·
Then there’s jail, or gaol, whose origin is given by Oxford as “Middle
English: based on L. cavea (see cage); the word came into Engl. in two forms,
jaiole from OFr. and gayole from Anglo-Norman Fr. gaole (surviving in the
spelling gaol).” If you drive Highway 1 to Winnipeg from Regina, you’ll pass a
sign that points to “Headingly Gaol.” The word is related to cage; an
interesting association very much in line with retribution.
·
Correctional Facility is a euphemism, a term that
softens impact, like “passing away” serves as a euphemism for “dying.” The
term also serves to emphasize the rehabilitation goal of incarceration.There's a mile of semantic difference, though, between correction and healing.
·
Prison conjures images of cages, like jail or gaol.
·
There is any number of pejoratives, some harking
back to the Wild, Wild West, Like hoosegow. Slammer, Big House and
a host of others spring to mind.
·
And then there’s Healing Lodge, a term that diverges
radically from the traditional and the typical, and leads us to see the rehabilitation goal most emphatically.
I find the interplay between cultural practices and
values and the words we use to talk about them fascinating. What major change
in cultural values would have to take place before we would begin calling the Prince Albert
Penitentiary the Prince Albert Healing Lodge?
As I understand it, the
concept of the healing lodge emanates
from the First Nations value of harmony among all aspects of being. Defined in
one study, “healing is ultimately about
the reparation of damaged and disordered social relations. The individual,
through outwardly and self-destructive behaviours, has become disconnected from
family, friends, community, and even his or her heritage. The reason for
undertaking healing is often found in the clients’ desire to make amends and to
be accepted back into the web of relationships. Healing, then, speaks to a form
of Aboriginal sociality that reduces the degree of self-indulgence and
self-pity and frames one’s problems and the solutions in broader, collective
terms.” (http://www.ahf.ca/downloads/aboriginal-healing-in-canada.pdf)
Victims
of crime can hardly be faulted if, in their bitterness, they can only visualize
justice as served if the perpetrator is made to feel suffering to a similar
degree that they are suffering. But surely the goal for a national justice
system can’t be focused just on making sure retribution happens. Prevention,
rehabilitation and reintegration have been undervalued and I would hope that
all the efforts made by those who work at restorative justice will eventually
produce a vibrant cultural value affecting how our justice system sets goals.
May
all our gaols finally have healing
lodges attached.
