Sunday, November 21, 2010

Slippery slope time - again

Feelings of frustration happen when circumstances block people’s ways to whatever goals they’d imagined. That many people should be living with mounting frustration at this time is not surprising, given the economic uncertainties. Prolonged frustration is like a cancer that eats away at the human spirit and when fed with a diet of bad news and very little prospect of change over time, it’s not surprising that frustration turns into rage. If frustration is the kitten, then rage is the tiger.

Frustration and rage can only live in a free-floating state for so long before they need to find some island on which to settle. In economically depressed, post WWI Germany, one island on which rage settled was Jewry, and we all know the end of that story. Once the cause of the frustration has been named and endorsed by a critical mass of others similarly frustrated, the running shoes are on and the stampede begins.

There’s plenty of frustration in the news these days. In North America (and to varying degrees, the rest of the world), a scary economic collapse in 2008 was bad enough, but followed by a period when little was heard except the good news of the recovery, the stagnation that turned out to be the fact pushed many people from frustration to rage. Demonstrations against government cuts to curb deficits got downright ugly in France and Greece particularly, and made us wonder if they were precursors to something really dangerous over here. 

Most of the media commentary on the economic situation here in Canada has been pretty cool and sane to this point. But there are signs that ideologues are working hard to point the rage of the masses toward certain targets. John Gormley is known for his right-wing views and in a recent column commenting on airport security, he couldn’t resist: Many of the people griping loudest about the imaging scanners and searches come from the new class of the special — those pampered, cherished, “ all about me” narcissists who continually star in their own movie and cling to the illusion that life really is all about them. (Saskatoon StarPhoenix, November 19, 2010, p.3) The labelling is clearly evident here; it points people toward a target against whom their rage would appropriately be directed.

In the USA, right-wing radio and television, the Tea Party phenomenon and all that goes with that have been much more clear about which targets people ought to blame for their frustrations. It’s the philosophical liberals in the country, represented by a) the Democrats, b) people who tolerate abortion, homosexuality and same-sex marriage and c) Muslims and anyone whose name sounds kind of Islamic. The fact that this is still a pretty big pond only means that the rhetoric is still waiting to find a clear focus. In a diatribe circulated on email networks called “I’m 63 and I’m Tired,” former contender for the Republican presidential nomination and a former district attorney on CSI Miami, Robert A. Hall names some of the islands on which the vultures of rage are invited to land. Here’s a sampling:

I'm tired of being told I must lower my living standard to fight global warming, which no one is allowed to debate. My wife and I live in a two-bedroom apartment and carpool together five miles to our jobs. We also own a three-bedroom condo where our daughter and granddaughter live. Our carbon footprint is about 5% of Al Gore's, and if you're greener than Gore, you're green enough.

I'm tired of being told that drug addicts have a disease, and I must help support and treat them, and pay for the damage they do. Did a giant germ rush out of a dark alley, grab them, and stuff white powder up their noses while they tried to fight it off? I damn sure think druggies chose to take drugs. And I'm tired of harassment from cool people treating me like a freak when I tell them I never tried marijuana.

I'm tired of illegal aliens being called "undocumented workers," especially the ones who aren't working, but are living on welfare or crime. What's next? Calling drug dealers, "Undocumented Pharmacists"? And, no, I’m not against Hispanics. Most of them are Catholic, and it's been a few hundred years since Catholics wanted to kill me for my religion. I'm willing to fast track for citizenship any Hispanic person, who can speak English, doesn't have a criminal record and who is self-supporting without family on welfare, or who serves honorably for three years in our military.... Those are the citizens we need.

Again, the pond is still pretty big, and as much as Hall may protest that, for instance, he is “not against Hispanics,” just being mentioned in this vitriolic dissertation is signal enough for some people.

I guess there is such a thing as being angry at oneself, but we don’t readily raise our hands and admit that, “I’m sorry; I did it.” Seems to me the economic morass is a direct consequence of far too many people - right, left, gay, straight, liberal, conservative - giving basic greed free rein for too long.

Be wary of people who name an enemy that doesn’t include themselves; we’re on a slippery slope here, folks.


  1. Thanks for a provocative piece.

    Your line , "Be wary of people who name an enemy that does not include themselves", was poignant.

    Someone, a fundamentalist Christian, likely found my sign on the highway, threatening. A hundred feet from my sign IMAGINE A WORLD WITHOUT WAR, someone put up a sign YES HEAVEN IS THIS PLACE. BELIEVE IN JESUS. It was up for nearly 2 days before I took it down. It was put up without the owner's permission.

    Fundamentalist evangelicals and military officials have always found peace alternatives threatening.

    JAke Buhler

  2. Thank you for posting my piece, "I'm Tired." I am not, however, the actor Robert D. Hall, on CSI. Someone assumed there could only be one Robert Hall in the world and added his photo and bio information as this went around the net.

    Nor am I a former 'republican Presidential Contender." State senators seldom are. Nor an I a "Fundamentalist evangelical and/or a military official" (unless you count a SSgt in the Reserves as being an official).

    People who wish to comment on it can find it on my blog: under February of 09. If you liked it, you may also like the posts below, or my almost daily political digest. ~Bob

    I’m Tired

    Why the Rich Should be Taxed More

    This I believe

    The Coming Collapse of the American Republic

    Reading List for the Educated Voter

    Seven Rules for Progressives

    My books

    Economic Facts of Life

    Why I’m a Republican

    Change that would fix America

    I’m dying

    Who’s eating your lunch?

    Global Warming Articles

    Historical figures look at the stimulus bill

    Agent Orange Fact Sheet

    E-mail courtesy and techniques

    A Religion of Peace?

    Angry Liberals

    When the guardians fail

    Reading list for the war on Terror

    The Next Terrorist attack on America
    Includes my 1998 column predicting 9/11

    Why the Future Looks Bleak

    Helping Obama

  3. I'm sorry, Robert Hall. The email was sent to me as you describe it and I'm leaving your links up for my readers to choose or not to choose to read.
    At the same time, I stand by my conviction that your comments are typical of a growing trend toward name-calling and denigration of a wide range of people who don't hold conservative views and see statements like the ones you make to be unfair in the extreme. Preying on the vulnerability of the angry is a vice we should recognize and learn to do without. It only serves to alienate people from each other when they should be talking to each other respectfully.

  4. On my blog piece, “This I believe”
    You quote me out of context. I said I don't believe in telling people what to believe ABOUT RELIGION.

    There are a lot of studies as to who gets hired, tenured and promoted at Universities, especially in the Liberal Arts. They are rarely Republicans or Conservatives.

    As to suggesting alternatives, read my blog for pieces like this:

    Change that would fix America

    The first step is to educate the public, of course:

    Reading List for the Educated Voter

    ~Bob Hall

  5. Thanks George. It is so much easier to blame than to take responsibility, thus starting us down the slope. To blame is to remain helpless, to take resposibility empowers one to make changes. Ron P.